Back to Blog
by Heather Mueller
Heather Mueller

3 min read

Benefits Of A Centralized Transportation Management Strategy

July 26, 2019

Heather Mueller
by Heather Mueller

Share:

Managing complex logistics networks poses large organizations a significant challenge. Most transportation footprints span various geographies across the US. This makes daily tendering and dispatching, carrier management, billing, compliance, and other factors that contribute to the health of a network require time and attention. Depending on how a shipper’s operations are organized, these activities might be handled by multiple teams responsible for specific regions, or by a single team of centralized operations.

Determining whether regional or centralized transportation teams are ideal depends on a host of factors, but the industry continues its decades-long shift towards centralization.

While regional transportation management teams work well for some shippers whose highly sensitive operations require proximity to the carrier base in each region, having geographically separated teams can also create challenges in communication and transportation management approach that lead to lost efficiencies and added cost.

Teams operating in separate regions may have completely different philosophies regarding how carrier relationships should be managed, how freight should be offered to carriers, and what constitutes quality performance. They may or may not agree with how routing guides are set. Each team may prioritize their beliefs about regional considerations over the company’s overarching transportation strategy. For most shippers, it is difficult to translate strategic priorities set through the sourcing and awards process into tactical-level results with regionally segmented operations. This highlights the benefits case for a centralized transportation management strategy.

Handling dispatching and carrier management functions centrally by one team makes it easier for the shipper to align to one set of goals and strategic priorities. The shipper can implement and maintain a single routing guide, rather than one that is engineered (and potentially altered in ways that do not align with the shipper’s carrier management policy or cost performance goals) separately at each operation. Subsequently, it is easier to create one set of ongoing performance standards so that all members of the transportation operations team are aligned on what good performance looks like. As operational challenges and carrier issues arise, they can all be analyzed and resolved by one team. When carriers contact the shipper, their concerns are addressed consistently no matter which region of the network their concerns pertain to.

Today’s systems and the availability of data make it possible for shippers to have a clear understanding of how well their transportation networks are performing. Data will show where quantifiable differences in cost performance and routing guide compliance between regions exist. In our experience, shippers that centralize operations show marked improvements in compliance and cost performance to plan. Their teams invest the most in understanding how they have performed against their plan, manage carriers consistently, and continuously look for ways to improve.

The most siloed operations with opaque tender and routing policies, “special” concerns, and carrier management strategy based on length of relationship at the origin point are those with the highest incremental cost to plan and lowest routing guide compliance.

3 min read

March 12, 2024

Navigate The Future Of Transportation With Breakthrough At The Gartner Supply Chain Symposium XPO

Breakthrough will be attending and presenting at the 2024 Gartner Supply Chain Symposium XPO.

Read more
Comprehensive Guide To The SEC’s Climate Disclosure Rule

5 min read

March 8, 2024

Comprehensive Guide To The SEC’s Climate Disclosure Rule

Explore how the SEC's Climate Disclosure Rule impacts shippers. Gain insights into the specifics and strategies to navigate the environmental reporting changes.

Read more
State-Level Decarbonization Initiatives And Their Impact On The Transportation Industry

5 min read

March 6, 2024

State-Level Decarbonization Initiatives And Their Impact On The Transportation Industry

Explore how cap-and-trade programs and clean fuel standards across states are influencing transportation. Learn what these policies mean for shippers’ networks.

Read more